This was forwarded to me, and it was too funny (and well-done) not to share. I am not sure which law school these students are at, but kudos to them. See the youtube video link below.
Author Archives: citizenyang
Clean Energy for Rural Pakistan
I was forwarded this news story about Shazia Khan, a former Vermont Law School student of mine, who is working to bring clean energy to rural Pakistan. Her non-profit, Eco Energy Finance, provides “electricity to remote areas of Pakistan for people whose lives are restricted when the sun goes down. Her idea is to harness solar power and turn it into electricity for villagers.” Great example of a social entrepreneur. Full story is here:
http://www.timesunion.com/local/article/Lighting-up-villagers-lives-5825741.php
Sept. 16 – World Ozone Day!
Today is world ozone day, as proclaimed by the United Nations. Thus, the reports last week, that the ozone layer has made a come back is great news.
Here’s me taking on the ALS ice bucket challenge issued to me by my student Andrew Palmer.
Notes on a Memorial Service for the late Vermont Law School Dean Jeff Shields
There was sad news from Vermont Law School a few weeks ago. First, there was Professor Cheryl Hanna’s suicide — made so much more tragic and unexpected because she was so widely admired in Vermont as a brilliant mind, popular teacher, and astute legal commentator in the media. I joined the VLS faculty just a few years after she did and was her colleague for quite a while. Over the years, Cheryl became well-connected within the state and was widely involved in many state-level policy issues. With her star rising, her sudden death seems that much more surprising (though her husband suggested in the press that it was attributable to depression).

Environment and Human Rights Law Symposium at Santa Clara University Law School, Jan 24-25, 2014
See the symposium agenda below. Please rsvp (via link on symposium webpage http://law.scu.edu/ai1ec_event/2014-journal-of-international-law-symposium-2/) if interested in attending. It will be on the Santa Clara campus.
http://law.scu.edu/ai1ec_event/2014-journal-of-international-law-symposium-2/
The 2014 Santa Clara Journal of International Law Symposium
“Environment and Human Rights Law”
Williman Room, Benson Center
Santa Clara University
Register for the symposium here
Keynote Speaker: Dinah Shelton
Symposium Schedule
Speaker Biographies
Abstracts of Conference Papers
Friday, January 24, 2014
Williman Room, Benson Center
|
9:00–9:30 a.m.
|
Registration, Refreshments
|
|
9:30–9:45 a.m.
|
Welcome
Tseming Yang, Professor of Law
John Fox, Editor-in-Chief of the Journal of International Law
Hazella Bowmani, Symposium Editor of the Journal of International Law
|
|
9:45–11:15 a.m.
|
Panel 1
The Human Right to a Healthy Environment
Rebecca Bratspies, City University of New York School of Law Commentators:
Marcos Orellana, Center for International Environmental LawMargarette May Macaulay, former Judge at the Inter-American Court of Human Rights
Moderator:
Francisco Rivera Juaristi, Santa Clara Law
|
|
11:15–11:30 a.m.
|
Break
|
|
11:30 a.m–1:00 p.m.
|
Panel 2
Promoting Food Security: Human Rights, the Environment and the Fragmented Nature of International Legal RegulationDonald K. Anton, Australian National University College of Law
Commentators:
Sumudu Atapattu, University of Wisconsin Law SchoolCarmen Gonzalez, Seattle University School of Law
Moderator:
Emily Yozell, Attorney, Costa Rica
|
|
1:00–2:30 p.m.
|
Lunch (and Special Lunchtime Presentation)
Speaker: Martin Wagner, Earthjustice
|
|
2:30–4:00 p.m.
|
Panel 3
Rehabilitation: A Proposal for a Compensation Mechanism For Small Island StatesMaxine Burkett, University of Hawaii, William S. Richardson School of Law
Commentators:
Damilola Olawuyi, University of Oxford, Faculty of LawRandall S. Abate, Florida A&M University College of Law
Moderator:
Natalie Bridgeman Fields, Accountability Counsel
|
|
4:00–4:15 p.m.
|
Break
|
|
4:15–5:15 p.m.
|
Keynote Address
Dinah Shelton, George Washington University
|
|
5:15-6:30 p.m.
|
Reception
Foyer, Arts & Sciences Building
|
Williman Room, Benson Center
|
8:30–9:00 a.m.
|
Breakfast
|
|
9:00–10:30
|
Panel 4
Indigenous Human Rights and the Ethics of “Remediation”: Redressing the Legacy of Uranium Contamination for Native Peoples and Native Lands
Rebecca Tsosie, Arizona State University, Sandra Day O’Connor College of Law Commentators:
Robert T. Coulter, Indian Law Resource CenterElizabeth A. Kronk Warner, University of Kansas, School of Law
Moderator:
David Takacs, UC Hastings College of the Law
|
|
10:30–10:45 a.m.
|
Break
|
|
10:45 a.m.–12:00 p.m.
|
Concluding Roundtable and Closing Remarks
|
Randall S. AbateRandall S. Abate is a Professor of Law, Director of the Center for International Law and Justice, and Project Director of the Environment, Development & Justice Program at Florida A&M University College of Law in Orlando, Florida. At Florida A&M, Professor Abate teaches Environmental Law, International Environmental Law, Environmental Justice: Domestic and International, Human Rights and the Environment Seminar, Advanced Topics in Environmental Law Seminar, Ocean and Coastal Law Seminar, and Constitutional Law I and II. Professor Abate joined the Florida A&M College of Law faculty in 2009 with fifteen years of full-time law teaching experience at Rutgers, Florida State, Florida Coastal, Widener, and Vermont. He has taught international and comparative environmental law courses in study abroad programs in Nairobi, Vancouver, Northern India, Buenos Aires, and the Cayman Islands. Professor Abate has published and presented widely on environmental law topics, with a recent emphasis on climate change law and justice. He is the co-editor (with Professor Elizabeth Kronk of the University of Kansas School of Law) of Climate Change and Indigenous Peoples: The Search for Legal Remedies (Edward Elgar Publishing 2013). In April 2013, he taught a climate change law and justice course in Odessa, Ukraine on a Fulbright Specialists grant. Early in his career, Professor Abate handled environmental law matters at two law firms in Manhattan. He holds a B.A. from the University of Rochester and a J.D. and M.S.E.L. (Environmental Law and Policy) from Vermont Law School.
Donald AntonDonald Anton is an Associate Professor at Australian National University and is a recognized expert in international law. He has appeared as Counsel in the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea and hasserved as Counsel and Attorney of Record for amicus briefs filed in Kiobel v. Royal Dutch Petroleum (SCOTUS) and Chevron v. Donziger (2nd Cir.). Professor Anton consults regularly with government and international organizations on matters of international law. He is currently leading an international team of researchers, funded by the Australian Government, in a three-year project testing underlying assumptions surrounding deep seabed mining by developing countries in the Asia pacific. Professor Anton has served in a variety of international law leadership positions. He is currently Co-Chair of the American Society of International Law International Environmental Law Interest Group. He was a Member of the International Law Association’s Committee on International Law on Sustainable Development, which produced the 2012 Sophia Guiding Statement on Judicial Elaboration of Sustainable Development. Professor Anton is a regular visiting professor at law schools and institutions around the world, including Michigan Law School, Yangon University Law Department, and the United Nations Institute of Training and Research.
Sumudu AtapattuSumudu Atapattu is the Associate Director of the Global Legal Studies Center at the University of Wisconsin Law School. She teaches seminar courses on “International Environmental Law” and “Climate Change, Human Rights and the Environment.” She has LLM and PhD Degrees from University of Cambridge and is an Attorney-at-Law of the Supreme Court of Sri Lanka. She has published widely on issues relating to sustainable development, human rights and the environment, and climate change and her book entitled Emerging Principles of International Environmental Law was published by Transnational Publishers in 2006. She is also the Lead Counsel for Human Rights at the Center for International Environmental Law, Montreal, Canada and is an Advisory Board Member of the McGill International Journal of Sustainable Development Law and Policy. Before coming to the United States, she was an Associate Professor at University of Colombo Law School and a Consultant to the Law & Society Trust in Colombo, Sri Lanka Her research interests include human rights and environment, climate change, environmental migration and sustainable development.
Rebecca BratspiesRebecca Bratspies is a Professor of Law at the CUNY School of Law where she is the founding director of the CUNY Center for Urban Environmental Reform. She has published widely on regulating under conditions of uncertainty—with a focus on environmental democracy, regulating new technologies and corporate responsibility. Her recent scholarship explores questions of sustainability, and the intersection of human rights and environmental regulation. She is a scholar with the Center for Progressive Reform, the Environmental Law Collective and has served as an appointed member of the ABA Standing Committee on Environmental Law, a member of the Executive Committee of the American Association of Law Schools Section on the Environment, and an advisor to the Consultative Group on Agricultural Research. Before entering academia, Professor Bratspies served as a judicial law clerk to the Honorable C. Arlen Beam of the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals. As a Henry Luce Foundation Scholar, Professor Bratspies spent a year seconded to the Republic of China (Taiwan) Environmental Protection Administration. She has taught at the University of Idaho, Michigan State University and NYU. She holds a BA in Biology from Wesleyan University and a J.D. cum laude from the University of Pennsylvania.
Natalie Bridgeman Fields
Maxine BurkettMaxine Burkett is a Professor of Law at the University of Hawaii, William S. Richardson School of Law who teaches Climate Change Law and Policy, Torts, Environmental Law, International Environmental Law, and International Development. She has written extensively in the area of climate change law and policy from diverse perspectives with a particular focus on climate justice, exploring the disparate impact of climate change on vulnerable communities in the United States and globally. Professor Burkett has presented her research on the law and policy of climate change throughout the United States and in West Africa, Asia, Europe and the Caribbean. In 2010, she served as the Wayne Morse Chair of Law and Politics at the Wayne Morse Center, University of Oregon, becoming the youngest scholar to have held the position. Professor Burkett also served as the inaugural Director of the Center for Island Climate Adaptation and Policy (ICAP). As the Director of ICAP, she led projects to address climate change law, policy, and planning for island communities in Hawaii, the Pacific region, and beyond. Prior to joining the University of Hawaii, Professor Burkett taught at the University of Colorado Law School. She studied at Oxford University, Exeter College and earned her B.A. from Williams College, and her J.D. from the University of California, Berkeley.
Robert T. CoulterRobert Coulter is an attorney who practices in the fields of Indian law and international human rights. He is the founder and Executive Director of the Indian Law Resource Center, which provides legal assistance for indigenous peoples throughout the Americas. He is also an enrolled member of the Citizen Potawatomi Nation and a Justice of the Supreme Court of the Citizen Potawatomi Nation. With more than 35 years of legal experience in the field of Indian affairs and human rights, Mr. Coulter has published numerous articles in these and other fields of law. Before starting the Indian Law Resoruce Center in 1978, he was Acting Executive Director of the Institute for the Development of Indian Law, staff attorney for the Native American Legal Defense and Education Fund and the United States Commission on Civil Rights. In 2001 Mr. Coulter was awarded the Lawrence A. Wein Prize for Social Responsibility by Columbia University Law School and in 2002 the Bicentennial Medal by Williams College. He received his bachelor’s degree from Williams College and his law degree cum laude from Columbia University Law School.
Carmen G. GonzalezCarmen Gonzalez is a Professor of Law at Seattle University School of Law. She has published widely in the areas of international environmental law, environmental justice, trade and the environment, and food security, and recently co-edited Presumed Incompetent, a book on the experiences of women faculty of color. She currently serves on the Board of Trustees of Earthjustice and on the Research Committee of the International Union for the Conservation of Nature (IUCN) Academy of Environmental Law. She is also a member scholar of the Center for Progressive Reform, a non-profit research and educational organization that seeks to inform policy debates regarding environmental regulation. From 2011 to 2012, Professor Gonzalez chaired the Environmental Law Section of the Association of American Law Schools. She has served as member and Vice-Chair of the International Subcommittee of the National Environmental Justice Advisory Council (an advisory body to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency on environmental justice issues), and has represented non-governmental organizations in multilateral environmental treaty negotiations. Professor Gonzalez received her B.A. in Political Science from Yale University and her J.D. from Harvard Law School.
Elizabeth A. Kronk WarnerElizabeth Kronk Warner is an Associate Professor of Law at the University of Kansas, School of Law where she teaches property, environmental and natural resources law and federal Indian law. She also serves as the director of the Tribal law and Government Center and as an Affiliated Professor of Indigenous Studies. Prior to joining the University of Kansas, she taught at Texas Tech University and the University of Montana. In 2010, Professor Kronk Warner was selected to serve as an Environmental Justice Young Fellow through the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars and U.S.-China Partnership for Environmental Law at Vermont Law School. In addition to teaching, Professor Kronk Warner serves as an appellate judge for the Sault Ste. Marie Tribe of Chippewa Indians Court of Appeals in Michigan. Before entering academia, Professor Kronk practiced environmental, Indian, and energy law as an associate in the Washington, D.C., offices of Latham & Watkins LLP and Troutman Sanders LLP. She previously served as chair of the Federal Bar Association Indian Law Section and was elected to the Association’s national board of directors in 2011. Professor Kronk Warner is a citizen of the Sault Ste. Marie Tribe of Chippewa Indians. She graduated from Cornell University with a Bachelor of Science in Communication and received her law degree from the University of Michigan Law School.

Margarette May Macaulay is a Jamaican attorney and former Judge at the Inter-American Court of Human Rights. Ms. Macaulay continues her practice as an Attorney-at-Law and women’s and children’s advocate, with her own Chambers in Jamaica. She has worked on several emblematic cases involving indigenous land rights. She is also a Notary Public and a Supreme Court Mediator and Associate Arbitrator, devoting her time to addressing matters of Constitutional and Fundamental Human Rights Law, Property Rights Law and Conveyance, General Contract Law, Estates Law and Criminal Law. Ms. Macaulay chaired the Family Law Committee of the Jamaican Bar Association and is a member of the Law Reform Committee, the Publications Committee, and the Human Rights and Constitutional Committee. She is a long serving member of the Disciplinary Committee of the General Legal Council of Jamaica. She is also a member of several human rights organizations nationally and internationally, including the
Damilola S. OlawuyiDr. Damilola S. Olawuyi, LL.M (Harvard), D.Phil (Oxford); is the Director (Research and Training) of the Institute for Oil, Gas, Energy, Environment and Sustainable Development (OGEES Institute) at Afe Babalola University, Nigeria. His research and published work cover the areas of International Environmental Law, Human Rights Law, Energy and Natural Resources Law. His current research explores the cross cutting linkages between global climate change and international human rights, particularly how climate change mitigation and adaptation projects could potentially affect the enjoyment of fundamental human rights. He has received several national and international awards including the Sloane Robinson Award, the World Energy Council’s Future Energy Leader’s Award, and the Alberta Law Foundation Scholarship Award.
Marcos A. OrellanaDr. Marcos A. Orellana (LL.M., S.J.D.) is Director of CIEL’s Environmental Health Program and Adjunct Professor at the American University Washington College of Law. At CIEL Dr Orellana has worked with NGOs and local communities worldwide to strengthen tools to protect the vital functions of the planet and secure global environmental justice, including with respect to chemicals and waste, oceans and biodiversity, and trade and investment. Prior to joining CIEL, Dr. Orellana was a Fellow to the Lauterpacht Research Centre for International Law of the University of Cambridge, UK. He also was a Visiting Scholar with the Environmental Law Institute in Washington DC and Instructor Professor of international law at the Universidad de Talca, Chile. Dr Orellana has acted as legal counsel to the Chilean Ministry of Foreign Affairs on international environmental issues. In that capacity Dr Orellana has worked with MEAs and the Rio+20 process. Dr Orellana has also acted as consultant to several International Institutions, including the UN Environment Programme and the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights.
Francisco Rivera JuaristiPrior to coming to Santa Clara University School of Law as founding director of the law school’s International Human Rights Clinic, Francisco was an adjunct professor of international law and human rights at the Inter-American University of Puerto Rico. He is a former senior staff attorney at the Inter-American Court of Human Rights of the Organization of American States seated in Costa Rica, where he was also director of that court’s internship program. In the late 1990s, he also served as Executive Director of the Amnesty International Section in Puerto Rico. He has been a consultant for a number of non-governmental organizations (NGOs), as well as for the United Nations Development Fund (UNDP), the International Labor Organization (ILO), and the Inter-American Institute of Human Rights (IIHR).
Dinah Shelton Dinah L. Shelton is the Manatt/Ahn professor of law (emeritus) at George Washington University Law School. Her extensive writing on international human rights has received many awards, including the 2005 New York Public Library Best Research Book Award, the 2000 Certificate of Merit from the American Society of International Law, and the 1982 Inter-American Bar Association Book Prize. In 2006, she was awarded the prestigious Elizabeth Haub Prize in Environmental Law and has also been awarded the Burhenne Prize in international environmental law (2012), the Riesenfeld award in international law (2013), the Goler T. Butcher Prize in human rights (2013), and the ASIL’s prominent woman in international law recognition. In 2011 she receive the degree of doctor honoris causa from the University of Stockholm.
David TakacsProfessor David Takacs is an Associate Professor at UC Hastings College of the Law. He has been a consultant for international NGOs and U.S. government agencies, analyzing legal and policy issues pertaining to REDD (Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and forest Degradation) and global climate change. His scholarly work lies at the intersection between international environmental and human rights law. He is the author of ”The Idea of Biodiversity” (Johns Hopkins U. Press). Before his legal career, Professor Takacswas a professor in Earth Systems Science & Policy at CSU Monterey Bay, a lecturer in the John S. Knight Writing Program at Cornell, and a Peace Corps Forestry Volunteer in Senegal. Professor Takacs holds a J.D. from Hastings, an LL.M. from the School of Oriental & African Studies at the University of London, and a B.S. in Biology, M.A., and Ph.D. in Science & Technology Studies from Cornell University.
Rebecca TsosieRebecca Tsosie is a Regent’s Professor of Law at Arizona State University, Sandra Day O’Connor College of Law. She teaches in the areas of Indian law, Property, Bioethics, and Critical Race Theory, as well as seminars in International Indigenous Rights and in the College’s Tribal Policy, Law, and Government Master of Laws program. Professor Tsosie has written and published widely on doctrinal and theoretical issues related to tribal sovereignty, environmental policy, and cultural rights, and her current research deals with Native rights to genetic resources. Professor Tsosie, who is of Yaqui descent, has worked extensively with tribal governments and organizations and serves as a Supreme Court Justice for the Fort McDowell Yavapai Nation. She annually speaks at several national conferences on tribal sovereignty, self-determination, and tribal rights to environmental and cultural resources. Professor Tsosie holds a bachelor’s degree and J.D. from the University of California, Los Angeles.
Martin WagnerMartin Wagner is the director of Earthjustice’s International Program, which promotes the protection of human rights to a clean and healthy environment through application of trade measures, international human rights and U.S. law. His work includes litigation against corporations before U.S. courts and international institutions for environmental practices that violate international human rights, including the the human right to a healthy environment. Mr. Wagner also teaches international environmental law and international trade and the environment at the Golden Gate University School of Law. Before coming to Earthjustice in 1996, Mr. Wagner was a law clerk for Judge Robert Beezer of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, and spent five years litigating environmental citizen suits in U.S. courts and representing victims of human rights violations in international institutions. Mr. Wagner graduated from Whitman College with a degree in geology and then became a community development volunteer with the Peace Corps in Senegal, West Africa. He attended the University of Virginia Law School, where he was executive editor of the Virginia Journal of International Law and graduated in the top ten percent of his class.
Minamata Mercury Convention Acceptance – pt2
I have been meaning to follow up on my earlier note about the Minamata Convention, but too many things going on, which I will post separately about.
First, here’s an interesting early comment on the US acceptance of the Minamata Convention, http://opiniojuris.org/2013/11/12/doesnt-u-s-senate-care-mercury/. The blog post raises the possibility of the US joining the Convention as a Congressional-Executive or as a sole executive agreement. Based on my understanding and also some conversations with folks in EPA and at State, the intention is to go at this as a sole executive agreement. As far as I know, this thinking is not being advertised anywhere. But given that there were consultations with Congress (at least the Senate, presumably), as I was told, such thinking must have been communicated (since that would be the first question any lawyer would ask), and the Senate (or some key senators) appears to be OK with this.
This is of course highly unusual. While the use of the sole executive power itself is not at all uncommon with respect to participation in international treaties, it is arguably unprecedented with respect to a major multilateral environmental agreement (though the US has used this device with respect to a subsidiary protocol to a major MEA). With MEAs, Congress has virtually always been involved, which would make especially great sense since these treaties oftentimes overlap and complement domestic environmental legislation.
On the other hand, most, if not all, of the treaty can already be implemented by EPA’s authority under the Clean Air Act (guess where all of the concepts/provisions about BAT came from . . . ) and TSCA, as well as the authority of other agencies. So, if one sees Congress’ role just as providing implementing tools, as opposed to giving its “approval” for US participation in the Minamata Convention, the Administration’s approach makes sense.
What’s curious is that there has not been more coverage of this. But I suppose that this is sufficiently technical that it would escape most journalists.
Op-ed on "Sue and Settle" Law Suits by Environmental Organizations
My op-ed piece on “sue and settle” law suits by environmental organization just started running in a number of newspapers. Here’s a link to the piece in the Deseret News:
*********
Tactic ensures EPA ignores politics; fulfills its mission
SANTA CLARA, Calif. — “Sue and settle” is the ominous phrase that has been attached to cases where an environmental organization sues a federal agency, such as the Environmental Protection Agency, and then settles the matter without going through a full-blown trial.
These tactics, while not ideal, are important to our environmental system because they hold agencies like EPA accountable for the important regulatory work they are required to do by law, but sometimes do not undertake because of politics or other reasons that the laws do not accept as a basis for delay.
It’s true that litigation is rarely optimal for good policy-making. When agencies avoid resolution of important environmental policy issues through unreasonable delay or other illegitimate means, however, they also avoid public accountability for their responsibilities.
Judicial intervention then becomes necessary to prompt them to do what they should be doing anyway. Only after agencies have followed the regulatory process required by law, rather than avoiding it, can the public, green groups, polluters and others scrutinize and debate the merits of “green policies.”
There is nothing nefarious about “sue and settle.” In the American legal system, the reality is that most cases — from simple slip-and-fall personal-injury suits to complex environmental enforcement actions — are settled to avoid the cost and uncertainties of trial.
“Sue and settle” cases usually involve EPA’s failure to take actions legally required by Congress, such as developing regulations by a certain deadline. When an agency knows that it is virtually certain to lose, as is characteristic of these cases, and the issues involved are serious environmental health or pollution problems, it makes little sense for the agency to run up legal costs and waste staff time just to delay the inevitable.
Take one environmental regulation pushed for by the American Lung Association: the mercury and air toxics regulation. It was adopted in 2011 to solve power-plant emissions of toxic substances like mercury and other pollutants that are hazardous to human health.
Polluters, who are vigorously fighting this regulation in the courts now, have argued that compliance costs will run into several billion dollars for the industry as a whole.
What is usually not mentioned is that the regulation will also prevent up to 11,000 premature deaths annually and save up to $90 billion in quantifiable health care costs each year.
Regardless of whether one agrees or disagrees with the regulation, the public process to promulgate the air toxics regulation has allowed everyone to scrutinize the agency’s decision and permitted those who object to get their day in court.
Without the American Lung Association’s original 2008 “sue and settle” lawsuit, such a public process might not have happened for a long time.
Polluters say their objection to “sue and settle” is all about “transparency” — the possibility that agencies like EPA might do something untoward in the settlement with less accountability than going through regular agency processes.
Such criticism seems ironic given that EPA settles litigation, such as enforcement actions, with polluters all the time, and judges must frequently approve environmental settlements.
More importantly, the result of such a lawsuit is almost always a very rigorous and very public rulemaking action in which all stakeholders can participate, contrary to what these suits typically forestall — unilateral and opaque agency commitments to inaction.
At the heart of the issue, however, is the fact that these settlements are primarily about actions that agencies are already legally required to take. By bringing these cases, environmental organizations seek to hold EPA accountable for properly protecting the health and environment of Americans.
Congress gave the public the right to sue, as a last resort for ensuring accountability for federal agency responsibility to protect the health and environment of all Americans. And that is what these cases do.
Tseming Yang is professor of international environmental law at Santa Clara University, and a former deputy general counsel of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. Readers may write to him at SCU Law, 500 El Camino Real, Santa Clara, Calif. 95050
*********
It is part of a dueling set of opinions on the question: “ARE THE “SUE AND SETTLE” TACTICS USED BY ENVIRONMENTAL GROUPS WITH THE EPA A LEGITIMATE WAY OF ADVANCING “GREEN POLICIES?”
The contrary opinion is expressed here:
http://www.deseretnews.com/article/865592857/Sue-and-settle-bypasses-democratic-process.html
So, here a few further thoughts.
First . . oof – difficult to express the complicated nature of this issue in 600 words. But even more difficult if the issue that one was asked to address gets recharacterized/refocused after one has written one’s piece. (In the Deseret News, the issue was presented as “Is the EPA circumventing the legislative process?”) Oh well, that’s the shakes.
Second, on the opposing opinion presented by William Kovacs – he presents the view articulated by the US Chamber of Commerce in their report and their views on the sue-and-settle cases. The framing of the issue by the paper (“is EPA circumventing the legislative process) ended up centering on what they wanted the public to focus on in their report.
Third, here are a couple reactions to Kovacs’ view point. The US Chamber report, which Kovacs wrote the intro to, is a fairly one-sided advocacy study; but I suppose that should not be surprising. One of the most disingenous parts of the study is its focus on cases brought by environmentalists and to exclude (via definition) from the scope of the study virtually all of the litigation and cases which mostly include polluters. That might have put some of these cases into context – but again, the report was never designed to be a fair study, I suppose. A second reaction is its disingenuous conclusion that EPA is deprived of discretion by such lawsuits when the US Chamber and polluters have made it their goal to limit the ability of EPA to do its job of protecting health and the environment. A third, and final, reaction is that one could also draw a wholly different conclusion about the implications of “sue-and-settle” cases. Rather than finding a remedy in making it more difficult for environmentalists to hold EPA accountable for fulfilling its Congressional mandates regarding environmental protection, how about providing the Agency with sufficient resources to do its job?
This last point is of course the ultimate rub of the US Chamber of Commerce’s report and Kovacs’ position – giving EPA the “freedom” to make what amounts to not much more than Hobson’s choices. Ironically, interest groups like the US Chamber have also been instrumentally part of efforts to put EPA into the catch-22, by restricting the resources of EPA to do its job . . . and it is the inadequacy of regulatory resources which is the root cause of why environmental organizations are bringing these sue-and-settle cases in the first place.
Never a dull moment . . .
Chengdu Visit
I was in China last week for some meetings/lectures and had the opportunity to visit the Giant Panda Research Station in Chengdu, Sichuan Province. This was my first time there, and it is an impressive facility. I must have seen at least 20-25 Giant Pandas, ranging from the very young to adults. The animals were mostly individually housed in large enclosures that mimicked their natural habitats. The entire station was large enough for me to wander around for more than a couple of hours. Here’s a picture of me with several adult Giant Pandas in the back.
Of course, also lots of air pollution in Chengdu, mostly because of vehicle emissions and coal use.
John Cruden to be nominated to be Assistant Attorney General for Environment Division at US DOJ
Here is some great news for the environment. The President is going to nominate John Cruden, currently President of the Environmental Law Institute, to be the next Assistant Attorney General for the Environment and Natural Resources Division at the US Department of Justice. Here’s the White House announcement:
http://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/2013/12/19/president-obama-announces-more-key-administration-posts
John will be taking the position previously held by Ignacia Moreno. At Santa Clara Law School, we are particularly proud because John is a SCU Law grad.





